From the Faceoff Factor:
When the Philadelphia Flyers began their overhaul at the trade deadline two seasons ago, it was clear the team had rebuilding in mind.
What wasn’t clear at that time was that the rebuilding process would last months, not years.
And that’s where the Flyers went wrong.
Their late season acquisitions of Braydon Coburn and Scottie Upshall looked great. Adding Martin Biron to the mix in goal wasn’t a bad idea either.
But what they did in the summer could haunt them for years.
They traded for, then signed impending free agents Kimmo Timonen and Scott Hartnell to six-year contracts. Timonen’s contract is worth $37.8 million ($6.3 million cap hit) and Hartnell’s is worth $25.2 million ($4.2 million cap hit).
For the record, Timonen’s deal has looked to be a solid decision, as he’s the anchor of the blueline and has played All-Star caliber hockey since his arrival.
Hartnell’s deal, however, is a joke. At $4.2 million, the Flyers paid nearly $1 million for every 10 points scored last season, though his physical presence was specular — even if it put the Flyers a man down quite often.
Then came the trade for Jason Smith and Joffrey Lupul. Smith looked to be the stoic veteran to lead the team, but ended up hurting them with poor positional play. He departed in free agency this summer. Lupul looked okay, registering 46 points, but that wasn’t nearly what was expected of the dynamic young forward.
And then there is the whammy: Danny Briere, a power play specialist softie, who is completely opposite of everything the Flyers stand for. He signed an eight-year deal worth $52 million ($6.5 million cap hit).
Also on the roster were talented youngsters Mike Richards, Jeff Carter, and R.J. Umberger, as well as veterans Mike Knuble and Derian Hatcher.
The lineup looked great on paper and finished the season with 95 points and ultimately went to the Eastern Conference Finals — a huge task, considering their league-worst 56 points the year before.
But their problems weren’t so much in last year’s roster, but this year’s roster and rosters for years to come.
By handicapping themselves with multiple big contracts for risky players, the Flyers have put themselves in a tough position under the cap.
The first consequence of the poor management led general manager Paul Holmgren to trade R.J. Umberger in the offseason to make room for some defensive upgrades.
And the upgrades made? Ossi Vaananen and Steve Eminger. Vaananen couldn’t find a suitor in the 2007-08 season, so he played overseas. Eminger couldn’t outplay his teammates on a relatively weak Washington Capitals blueline in 2007-08, so he watched from the press box on most nights.
Now, with defensemen Ryan Parent and Randy Jones sidelined until the new year at the earliest, the Flyers defensive depth — which already was quite bad — looks even worse.
Fans are calling for help, some even suggesting signing Mats Sundin (how does that help the team’s defensive woes?).
But what is handicapping the Flyers is their recklessness in handing out big contracts.
According to Cap Central, the Flyers have six players making more than $4 million this season, and next season they’ll have another. All seven of those players are locked in until 2010-11, and five of them will remain under contract until 2012-13.
So, to break that down, the Flyers currently have $33.03 million tied up in six players. Next season, they’ll pay $37.28 million to seven players. In 2011-12 and 2012-13, the Flyers will spend $27.03 on five players. And they’ll still have at least one big contract on the hook through 2015-16.
Big contracts in some cases aren’t bad. In fact, in some cases — Timonen and Richards, for example — they’re quite good. In Timonen and Richards, they have their star defenseman and team captain locked in long-term.
But, in other cases, they have risky players signed for big bucks. Hartnell at $4.2 million per year, Lupul (beginning next season) at $4.25 million per year, and Briere at $6.25 per year for the next seven years (including this year) just don’t help the team.
Where is the money to be spent on defense? How will they improve if they have more than half of their payroll tied up in less than one third of their roster?
Maybe they’ll make some trades. But who would be willing to take some of the large contracts they’ve issued to mediocre players?
Maybe a player or two will retire. But, wait, none of the big-money players listed above is nearing retirement, and those close to retirement (Hatcher at $3.5 million, Mike Rathje at $3.5 million) aren’t even counted in the team’s salary structure, which currently sits just $1,638,333 below the salary cap — even with several players on long-term injured reserves.
Rebuilding isn’t something that can or should be done in a one-year span. Teams that do it right — Pittsburgh, Los Angeles and Chicago, to name a few — let the process work out itself.
Some may say these teams purposefully stunk for years to stockpile high draft picks, but the fact is, these teams built for the long haul, with the entire picture in mind.
Unfortunately for Flyers fans — and for those who enjoy good competition when their team plays the Flyers — the 0-3-3 start appears to be more of a forecast for the future than a sign of a temporary slump.
