I know 2 of these these are old proposals what I didn't mention that? Jason Arnott doesn't play for the stars either.

i went a read back on some, haha they arent so bad at all compared to this garbage.

thats probably the dumbest trade proposal i've ever seen

and i agree 100% on the bouwmeester crap... dont people understand knuble for bouwmeester straight up wont work?

whoever thought these up should be shot

I don't think the Canucks deal is thaaaat bad. I mean, I wouldn't do it from a Flyers perspective, but from what I've seen on Center Ice, Edler and Raymond are already great players, and they also have great potential. I'd say Edler and Coburn are a wash, while Carter is further along than Raymond. So yeah, to sum things up, I wouldn't do it either, but I don't think it's as bad as some of you are making it out to be.

I guess it's just that there's no need to make a deal that does nothing to improve the team. And there's a lot of Coburn love on this board. We stole him and that makes people happy.

I see a lot of Canuck games since I live in Vancouver. Edler is a good defenceman and Vancouver won't trade him. Raymond well I dunno, sure he's a fast skater but he coughs up the puck too much, and Giroux, JVR are way better than him.

So Coburn >> Edler.

haha

nice.

maybe i'd trade Bouwmeester to us for knuble and a set of prosthetic hips.

Whatever Canadian weed they are on I definitely need some! Next the Canucks will trade us the Sedin twins for Riley Cote and Knuble!!

I wouldn't do Gagner and a first round pick for Kaberle.

That is too much skill and youth for Kaberle. He has at max 4 good years left. He is solid don't get me wrong but too much youth gets traded for aging players.

Be happy you don't live with Canuck fans

No I live in Vancouver.

You've listed all the positives about Krajicek but god, their are a bunch of negatives too. 1stly, he can't keeps his own space on the ice so unless you want to see him gone for most of the season don't use him as a forward! 2ndly, even with size Lukas doesn't desere a top four spot on any teams defense. He isn't worth it and I see him taking away talent if you give him top pair time. Lukas has been on the bottom lines of defense so I say this to any team, keep him there!

Oh and Pyatt is better than you think. He can hit very nicely, he can get in those hard - to - get places and he's very good at chipping in, in front of the net. Like Pyatt could end up being a main - stay on any teams 2nd line but he's got versatility so he could play as a scorer and offensive guy on your 2nd line but hecould also be a defensive guy and do good on your checking line. So I'm not saying he's a perfect version of Hartnell, I just think he deserves more credit tha you give him.

Krajiceks not that good. bottom pairing guy in my opinion. He just doesn't have it